Chef Oya's The TRAP, located in Indianapolis, has quickly established itself as a must-visit seafood destination, drawing locals and travelers alike. Reviewers consistently emphasize the incredible value and delicious flavors that make the wait worthwhile. On offer are standout dishes like the Loaded Salmon and Shrimp and the island curry loaded shrimp, with many praising the tenderness and freshness of the seafood.
Customer experiences vary, from initial ordering challenges through a plastic cutout window to the tantalizing rewards of the meal. One enthusiastic diner noted the chowder's remarkable quality, declaring it even better than what is found in Boston. Highlighting the communal anticipation, others encourage prospective customers to arrive early to avoid missing out on specials, as popular items tend to sell out.
While seating is minimal—encouraging a takeout-only model—this adds a unique charm to the casual dining experience. The line may be long, but the positive feedback confirms that Chef Oya's The TRAP provides an unforgettable taste of seafood, creating eager repeat patrons. Overall, it’s not just a meal; it’s a culinary journey worth taking.
Amenities and More
From the business
Identifies as Black-owned
Identifies as women-owned
Service options
Outdoor seating
Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
Comfort food
Quick bite
Vegetarian options
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Trendy
Crowd
Family friendly
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safe space
Planning
Usually a wait
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Parking
Photos
Reviews For Chef Oya's The TRAP
LadyButterfly Love
Jun 30,2025
1st timer & OMG it was everything I expected it to be. Loved it! Was worth the wait, in line that is. Would definitely go back. Had the loaded salmon and shrimp. Got it on a special she was running 2 for 25. Also got some chowder "AMAZING" #recomended
Bryan Laur
Jun 18,2025
So you go up to a window to order. There is a small plastic cutout, and It's really difficult to hear the person and they aren't so friendly. There is a speaker that cuts in and out. You order and they turn around and you receive it in about 3 minutes flat. Nothing is made to order. The broccoli was cold. But as long as you know what you're getting, this is an incredible value. I got the island curry loaded shrimp for 15. Shrimp was tender and basically perfect. I can't attest to the crab or lobster but I'd certainly be willing to give them a try next time. I just wish they had a place to sit or something. Just put a table out there somewhere. Oh, and why do we need a plastic cutout window? I guess it's the charm of the place but c'mon. Whatever 5 stars anyways.
Angela T
Jun 15,2025
Amazing! Worth waiting even in the cold outside! The chowder is better than what I had in Boston!!!!!!! I had the shrimp platter and my husband had the shrimp 5 ways The sides were good, broccoli, potatoes and an ear of corn as well as a boiled egg all slathered in the butter and spice of your choice. This is take out ONLY You will be waiting outside but again so worth it. Go early otherwise they might run out of what you plan on getting.
Ervin Gainer
Jun 3,2025
My first time trying Chef Oya's The TRAP. I ordered today's special: Loaded All Shrimp Tray and it is !!! Only 15. I will be back!!!
Christopher Schurrer
May 23,2025
It is by far worth the trip from Illinois to try this place out. I've been trying to make it for several years now. I just always passed their open hours. (Wed - Sat 11A-3P). I had the Loaded Salmon and Shrimp. spicy with Yaad Jerk, and a Mystery Flamemade. This has to be one of the best seafood trays I've had. Wonderful flavor of the sauce mix. Great Sides mixed in with it and the Salmon and Shrimp were super fresh. Now that I've made it. I'm going to be making the trip again and again. The place to be on Keystone!
Danis Pelmore
Apr 19,2025
Came to visit my brother, and he took me here. Best place in Indy!!! If you haven't been you missing out.
Nadia Terrell
Mar 23,2025
This was my first time visiting and I Will definitely be back! Nice portions, well seasoned and didn’t break the bank! I had the loaded crab legs and shrimp and it was delicious!
Brooke Shoopman
Mar 7,2025
The best seafood in Indianapolis without any question. Worth the wait and definitely worth many return trips to try everything on the menu. The shrimp is tender and juicy, all veggies are perfectly seasoned, and the salmon fell apart on my fork. Boyfriend had the lobster tail and it blew my mind even more.
Reviews For Chef Oya's The TRAP